Essay
Moving away from WordPress after more than ten years inside it
I built on WordPress for more than ten years, ran a company around it and spoke at WordCamp Europe. AI made leaving cheap. Years of building on someone else's platform made me want to.
Until 30 September 2026, octooai.com ran on WordPress. Now it is a static site built with Astro, an open-source framework for websites, written largely by AI coding agents under my direction. I still recommend WordPress for many sites, and at the end I say which ones.
Ten years on the inside
I started building for the open web in 2008: plugins, themes, communities. In 2011 I founded ThemeKraft, a company focused on WordPress, ran it as CEO for many years and contributed to BuddyPress, the community plugin for WordPress. At WordCamp Europe 2018 in Belgrade I talked about user-generated content, the idea BuddyPress is built around, and I still see it that way.
Themes and plugins carried my work for years. When I call WordPress the right tool for its time, I mean it.
Is WordPress dead? What it got right, and still does
WordPress has one advantage that rarely makes the feature lists. When thousands of sites run the same code, somebody out there understands it: you can hire for it, and the error message on your screen has usually been answered somewhere already.
WordPress still runs about 40% of all websites, according to W3Techs, and in 2026 it built an AI interface into its core. So, is WordPress dead because of AI? No. What AI changes is the price of the alternative.
Custom website vs WordPress: the assumption that changed
Custom software used to lose to WordPress on upkeep. Every purpose-built system needed someone who understood it, and when that person left, the knowledge left too. A standard CMS was the insurance: code a whole industry could read. I made that trade for clients myself.
AI coding agents move the cost. An agent can now work through an unfamiliar codebase, document and test it, update it and build the next feature. That often makes it cheap enough to build the system around the business instead of bending the business to the CMS.
The other reason: whose platform is it?
Cheaper upkeep made leaving possible. The wish to leave grew over more than a decade of publishing through wordpress.org, a chapter that closed for me when I sold ThemeKraft’s plugins and themes. The deal there is simple: the directory gives you reach, and its rules and the people who run it decide what it lists.
Custom Community, a free theme I put into the directory in 2010, became a featured theme and passed half a million downloads. In 2015 a new rule moved every theme option into the Customizer, the WordPress settings screen with a live preview, existing themes included. We rebuilt our theme early, and I wrote on our blog that the change nearly destroyed our business. One team meeting had changed the economics of a product a company lived on.
Between 2022 and 2023 our form plugin BuddyForms was closed three times: once over an email problem with my account, twice after security reports. A closed plugin gets no downloads and no updates from wordpress.org, so the more than 2,000 sites running it got nothing from there. In January 2023 our fix shipped on the day of the closure, then waited weeks for a full review of the whole plugin. In my view a finished security fix should reach users first.
In 2024 the same question played out in public: during a legal dispute with Automattic, wordpress.org cut off the host WP Engine, and in December a US court ordered it reversed.
If you build on wordpress.org today, use the reach and own what the directory can switch off: your update channel, your line to your users, your code. Cheaper building makes that affordable now, even for a small company.
What moving away from WordPress looked like here
The new octooai.com is static HTML built with Astro, plus one small script for the contact form: no theme, no plugins, no database, no admin screen. AI coding agents write and test the code. They deploy when I say so, I sign off on everything that cannot be undone, and every deploy can be rolled back. WordPress itself went into an archive folder, not the bin. Astro vs WordPress compares the two in detail.
WordPress to Astro migration: a 301 or a 410 for every old URL
This part is easy to skip, and it is where a migration quietly throws away the old site’s search history.
Google’s advice for a site move is plain: map the old URLs to new ones, use permanent redirects, keep them for at least a year and submit the new sitemap in Search Console. Our rule: an old URL gets a 301 redirect only if a new page really does the job the old one did. Everything else gets 410 Gone.
We use 410 instead of 404 because it says what we mean: this page existed, and it was removed on purpose.
When I would still choose WordPress
Leaving has a price: there is no editor any more, so every change to a page is a change to a file. That works for me because agents do most of the typing. For a business where five people edit pages every day, it would be a step backwards.
| Situation | My pick |
|---|---|
| Several non-developers edit content every day | WordPress |
| A community with members, profiles and groups | WordPress with BuddyPress or BuddyBoss |
| A shop whose process fits existing shop plugins | WordPress with WooCommerce |
| The plugins and workarounds decide what the business can do | Time to rethink the architecture |
| The site has to talk to APIs, internal data, AI models or agents | Purpose-built |
Watch the fourth row. Until a business gets there, keeping WordPress is usually the cheaper and calmer choice. How we build the alternative is on the Autonomous Web page.
Common questions
Is WordPress dead because of AI?
No. WordPress still runs about 40% of all websites, and in 2026 it built an AI interface into its core. What AI changes is the cost of building and maintaining the alternative, so a custom site makes sense more often than it used to.
Why are people moving away from WordPress?
The reasons differ. Mine were two: AI coding agents made a purpose-built site cheap to keep alive, and after more than a decade of publishing through wordpress.org I wanted to own what I publish and how it reaches people.
When should you not use WordPress?
When the plugins and workarounds start dictating what the business can do, or when the site has to work as software connected to APIs, data and AI agents. If several non-developers edit content every day, WordPress is usually still the better fit.
Is a custom website better than WordPress for SEO?
Not by default. A well-built WordPress site and a well-built custom site can both deliver clean HTML, stable URLs and fast pages. The bigger risk is the move itself, which is why Google recommends permanent redirects for moved URLs, kept for at least a year.
How do you migrate from WordPress to Astro without losing SEO?
List every old URL. Give each one that has a real successor a 301 redirect to that page, and let the rest return 410 or 404. Keep the redirects for at least a year, submit the new sitemap in Search Console and test the old URLs after every deploy.
Sources
- W3Techs: Usage statistics and market share of WordPress w3techs.com
- WordPress.org News: WordPress 7.0 “Armstrong” wordpress.org
- Google Search Central: Site moves with URL changes developers.google.com
- WP Tavern: Court grants WP Engine preliminary injunction against Automattic wptavern.com
- WordPress.tv: Sven Lehnert, How to Create User Generated Content for Your WordPress Website and Business (WordCamp Europe 2018) wordpress.tv
WordPress, Astro and WP Engine are trademarks of their respective owners. Naming them does not imply endorsement by, or a business relationship with, OCTOO AI. WooCommerce and its associated designs are trademarks of Automattic Inc.
